Skip to main content

Publication Details

Limits of Representation: Charles Sanders Peirce and Nelson Goodman on Representation

(Original title: Limity reprezentácie: Charles Sanders Peirce a Nelson Goodman o reprezentácii)
Filozofia, 76 (2021), 8, 608 - 623.
Type of work: Original Articles
Publication language: Slovak

Philosophical conceptions of representation developed by Nelson Goodman and Charles Sanders Peirce come from different metaphysical positions (Goodman’s nominalism and Peirce’s realism). This fact causes serious problems when comparing both conceptions and often results in inaccuracies or oversimplifications. The aim of this paper is to find a framework for the comparison of the two conceptions of representation and consider their possible role in understanding representation as a source of knowledge. The first and the second part of the paper shortly introduce Peirce’s and Goodman’s conceptions of representation. Subsequently, a comparison of these conceptions is proposed in the context of limits of our representations. The limits of representations are suggested as a basis for further comparison without the need to reject one of the conceptions. The conclusion outlines some consequences of this approach for the analysis of representations as a source of knowledge.


Charles Sanders Peirce, Comparison, Nelson Goodman, Representation, The limits of representation

File to download: PDF